theFarWilds.com
http://thefarwilds.com/forum/

[Suggest] Wilds Card Ban Voting
http://thefarwilds.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=8&t=1613		 Page 1 of 1
Author:  UBER [ Wed Feb 03, 2010 11:32 am ]
Post subject:  [Suggest] Wilds Card Ban Voting
I was looking through threads about the wilds and I think this would be a good idea.

Players with 50 or more post could suggest cards for banning and then vote on banning them. You wouldnt need some nifty auto matic vote calculator with buttons on it. You could use the forum and tally up the votes.
Author:  Nighthawk42 [ Thu Feb 04, 2010 7:07 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: [Suggest] Wilds Card Ban Voting
I think that a better way to run the wilds would be for players to put a set of cards in like a normal deck and that would be their deck for the game. Cards could still be added, but destroyed cards would go to the bottom of the deck rather than disappearing.

As far as banning cards, maybe Carrion Feeders. The Nothing and Lost Oasis have the potential to be very powerful as well if someone is willing to invest the gold.
Author:  UBER [ Sun Feb 07, 2010 11:05 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: [Suggest] Wilds Card Ban Voting
Thats also a good idea.

Limiting card entry.
Author:  jed [ Wed Feb 10, 2010 4:21 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: [Suggest] Wilds Card Ban Voting
Sure suggest cards that you think should be banned. Cards like carrion feeder and lost oasis wont be banned. Things like that that are just more powerful in the Wilds than the regular game will be handled by the meta game. Things that get banned are things like bard's inspiration that just have no effect in the wilds.

these are the cards that are currently banned if you are curious:

Buildings: (7x)
1x Loxlorn Globe
1x Astridian Forum
1x Goblin Slave Market
1x Astridian Geographic Society
1x Temple of Zorn
1x Cathedral of Xosa
1x Gilded Organ

Creatures: (13x)
1x Paladin of Xosa
1x Corathian Draft Roc
1x Galog Bullfrog
1x Veldan Unicorn
1x Toothless Mastodon
1x Yarl Chieftain
1x Errant Enchantment
1x Dellenari Beastmaster
1x Caravan of Dreams
1x Cargo Fluyt
1x Geomantic Trickster
1x Serene Templar
1x Silver Stagg

Enchants: (18x)
1x Cold Snap
1x Flash Flood
1x Bard's Inspiration
1x Benefits of Numbers
1x Benefits of Spectacle
1x Vow of Peace
1x Benefits of a Clear Mind
1x Lycanthropy, Bear
1x Benefits of Wisdom
1x Encircling Sea
1x Tales of Yore
1x People's Champion
1x Unstable Reality
1x Sigvatr's Arena
1x Crush of the Unknown
1x Vortex
1x Reserves
1x Overclock

Spells: (7x)
1x Knowing Despair
1x Humiliation
1x Skulduggery
1x Heat Wave
1x Fissure
1x Downpour
1x Transcendence

Total: 45
{deck,LUnHxSIBbKYDRgGMOkupAR9evykBaJfnmgF9mrilAayji0cBiQlhDAHiK2TXAcUAokgBYryibQEh3QS6AQ71sjgB95mTSQEf2m8iAVUBwgIBVOF21wEgFhP0AZiCy4sB+8TQVQFNn9tYAdzjAwYBHOe2vAG252eAATJnbssBmbyqBgEKr2/XAYfIuisBk6SmUQGjmZR5AafcsQ0B8eeASAFq9NECAcQe3/cB+XQ2FgFdVUNfAV5574IBjZu2OQFKUf10ATr/0vEBS9ulFQEWeY+gAVktJSsB7m4PJQEAa/WIAQ==,Mog Ban}
Author:  Nighthawk42 [ Wed Feb 10, 2010 7:50 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: [Suggest] Wilds Card Ban Voting
I don't understand why a lot of these are banned.
Some were pretty obvious so I pulled them from the list.

Others are less obvious.


Some issue with Taken?
1x Loxlorn Globe
1x Corathian Draft Roc
1x Cargo Fluyt
1x Transcendence
1x Galog Bullfrog
1x Errant Enchantment
1x Lycanthropy, Bear

Penalty on death doesn't work with scoring?
1x Paladin of Xosa
1x Yarl Chieftain
1x Serene Templar

1x Dellenari Beastmaster - Why?
1x Geomantic Trickster - Issue with not resetting when it dies?
1x Silver Stagg - Why?
1x Astridian Geographic Society - So it reveals the whole map for everyone? That's what it's supposed to do.
1x Temple of Zorn - Seems like this would work pretty much the same way in the Wilds that it does normally.
1x Flash Flood - Possibly abusive, but I thought you weren't banning things based on power?
Author:  UBER [ Thu Feb 11, 2010 9:59 am ]
Post subject:  Re: [Suggest] Wilds Card Ban Voting
I think its illogical to not ban cards based on power. What works for one game format will not work completely for another. The round pegs do not fit in the triangle hole.
Author:  Nighthawk42 [ Mon Feb 15, 2010 3:28 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: [Suggest] Wilds Card Ban Voting
Yes. A clear example from another format is Flux Capacitor in Battle Draft....
Page 1 of 1 All times are UTC
Powered by phpBB © 2000, 2002, 2005, 2007 phpBB Group
http://www.phpbb.com/